The Top 10 of TIFF 2019
New year, new TIFF record: I managed to see 38 films this year, a personal best. Here is my Top 10, with the caveat that I intentionally skipped some big profile releases, like “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood”, “Ford vs Ferrari”, “Dolemite Is My Name” (due to them being released in theaters soon), or “The Goldfinch” (due to seemingly every critic at the festival shitting on it). Also, I missed out on tickets to 2 films that would’ve probably made this list: “Parasite” (Bong Joon-ho’s Palme d’Or winner) and “Knives Out”.
The Lighthouse (Robert Eggers) – 10 on 10
Wow. Just wow. This is exceptional filmmaking from a young director who just proved “The Witch” wasn’t an accident. Brilliantly directed, written and shot, and anchored by two incredible performances – especially Willem Defoe’s, who seems to have been born for this role – “The Lighthouse” is a joy from start to end. Its characters are genuinely interesting, and having them stuck on an island makes the film feel like a stage play at times, one with infectious, incredibly authentic period dialogue.
Eggers’ attention to detail is, once again, astounding. This was shot on old 35mm black and white film stock, in a weird 1.19:1 aspect ratio, and it looks fantastic. Between the gorgeous, painting-like cinematography, gripping story, and amazing dialogue, I couldn’t take my eyes off the screen. Best movie of the year so far, and it will take something really special to dethrone it.
Joker (Todd Phillips) – 9 on 10
Things I never thought I’d say:
Todd Phillips made an Oscar-worthy movie
Heath Ledger is not the best Joker anymore
DC made a “comic book movie” that’s actually a character drama
“Joker” is everything I could possibly hope for as an origin story for this character. It’s bold, violent, furious, and goes to some places comic book movies never did. Also, Joaquin Phoenix is one of the greatest actors alive, and he proves it once again.
The Vast of Night (Andrew Patterson) – 9 on 10
Probably the biggest surprise of the festival for me. This debut feature from Andrew Patterson is a joy to watch. It’s an exquisite homage to all things fifties, and sci-fi, and The Twilight Zone. It’s so refreshing to see a film do things differently. This is a very simple tale about aliens, but it’s done so confidently, and is spectacularly written, shot and acted. The dialogue is great and flows naturally, the story develops without the need of expensive effects (this was probably a very low budget film), but it catches on to you and never lets go. The atmosphere of the town, and the camerawork, is all exemplary. The two (minor) things that kept me from rating this a perfect 10 are the abrupt ending that left me wanting something more, and the sometimes overly done exposition in the story telling scenes.
This was just picked up by Amazon during the festival, so make sure you watch it when it’s out.
A Hidden Life (Terrence Malick) – 9 on 10
This is such an amazing, moving, important film, and easily Malick’s best since “The Tree of Life”. It keeps Malick’s unmistakable gorgeous style intact, but, unlike his last couple of films, is considerably less self-indulgent, and has a coherent plot you can actually follow. The true story of an Austrian farmer who refuses to pledge allegiance to Hitler during World War II, “A Hidden Life” is sentimental and poetic, but also urgent and extremely relevant in today’s society.
Jojo Rabbit (Taika Waititi) – 8 on 10
I expected this to divide critics, and it seems like it does. For me, it worked. It’s hilarious, and relentlessly entertaining, even when the tone shifts towards more serious matters towards the end. It does play it safe at times, but it never wavers from its message, its characters are interesting, the lead kid actor is great, and the jokes are aplenty.
Sound of Metal (Darius Marder) – 8 on 10
Riz Ahmed’s incredible performance highlights a really solid movie about a metal drummer losing his hearing, and trying to deal with his new condition. Marder’s film, while predictable plot-wise, and dragging a bit in its second half, excels at pretty much everything else. Ahmed is the standout, but the memorable use of sound design is a close second. Much of the movie is spent with the viewer hearing what the main character is – sounds are constantly muted or distorted. It’s extremely well done, and extremely immersive.
Color Out of Space (Richard Stanley) – 8 on 10
Psychedelic colorful horror that blends Cronenberg and “Mandy” to great effect. It starts off slowly, and feels like a “Twilight Zone” episode early on, but the insanity is cranked up to 11 in a brilliant final act, full of madness, color, alpacas, Crazy Cage, and straight up body horror weirdness. It’s a flawed film that doesn’t always work, and it takes forever to get to the good part, but when it does, it’s amazing. I just wish the whole trippy gorgeous painting-like madness started a bit earlier, to mask some of the early issues.
Bacurau (Juliano Dornelles, Kleber Mendonça) – 8 on 10
It’s tough to talk about this without giving away the shift the movie takes in its second half, which is best experienced going in blind. Let’s just say this is an excellent, crazy film, about a tight-knit Brazilian community during some dark times in the future. The first half is excellent, a nice glimpse into the life of this village and their interesting characters, dealing with the death of one of their members, and with increasingly weird happenings, like not being able to find their town on the map, or some suspicious bikers going through town, or a drone following the locals. Then it gets crazy. The second half is pure, fun, violent bliss. The movie is extremely relevant in today’s political landscape, and delivers its message in shocking, entertaining ways.
Guns Akimbo (Jason Lei Howden) – 8 on 10
You either like over-the-top, crazy, stylish, mindless, pointless, bloody, brutal, fun, fast-paced, gorgeous violence, or you don’t. I do.
Deerskin (Quentin Dupieux) – 8 on 10
I feel like Quentin Dupieux has decided that every one-liner idea he has (probably while high) needs to be turned into a movie. Easily his best film since “Rubber”, this is yet another extremely absurd comedy, this time about a jacket instead of a tire. Oscar award winning actor Jean Dujardin is all in as a jacket owner who goes a bit crazy. The movie is at times hilarious, the absurdity of the situation being made even better by how grounded in reality everything else is. I also appreciated that it’s all just over an hour long, which is the right amount of time before everything could have become tedious.
Honorable mentions
The Long Walk (dir. Mattie Do) – 8 on 10
A great follow-up to Mattie Do’s previous acclaimed film, “Dearest Sister”, this follows on the same formula of interesting characters in a weird story that mixes genres. This is another slow burner, that takes its sweet time unveiling its secrets, and by the time you figure out what’s going on, you realize a second viewing is in order. And yes, it involves ghosts and time travel, and poses plenty of existential questions.
Saint Maud (dir. Rose Glass) – 7 on 10
Really solid, effective chiller, carefully executed, really well acted, and telling the interesting story of a religious nurse caring for a dying patient while struggling with her beliefs, Rose Glass’s feature debut is just as much a character drama as it is a horror film. It explores and unveils the layers of the lead character slowly and carefully, building up to a satisfying final act.
True History of the Kelly Gang (dir. Justin Kurzel) – 7 on 10
Justin Kurzel’s retelling of the famous Australian outlaw Ned Kelly’s story is violent and spectacular, but also marred by a lack of characters to root for, since everyone is either evil or worse. The film doesn’t glorify Kelly’s deeds, nor paint him in a good light. The story is at times poetic, at others a bit meandering, but always gorgeous, Kurzel’s visual style, also present in his previous films “Macbeth” and “Assassin’s Creed”, being, again, front and center.